New report exposes gap between levelling up rhetoric and reality

Influential think-tank IPPR North has published new research showing that despite the rhetoric, the UK is more regionally divided than ever – and that central government policy has so far undermined the levelling up agenda.

More than two years on from the government’s promise to ‘level up’ the country, IPPR North - which turns 18 this week - unveils stark results in its annual health-check of the economy of the north of England. 

• Funding for ‘levelling up’ pales in comparison to local government austerity: The 2021 allocations of the Levelling Up Fund, which is controlled by central government, is an investment of just £32 per person in the north. This compares to a £413 per person drop in the north, and a £388 drop across England, in annual council service spending over the last decade;
• The country is becoming more centralised: Public spending is concentrated in central government. Four years ago, 95p in every £1 paid in tax was taken by Whitehall (compared to just 65p in Germany). Despite the levelling up agenda, this has now increased to 96p;
• Regional divides are growing across a range of measures: For example, for every job created in the north, just under three were created in London and the 'Greater South East’;
• There are real, significant consequences for people, with in-work poverty rising in the north from 3.4 million people in 2009/10, to 3.5 million in 2019/20.

IPPR North’s research also includes a new levelling up promises tracker, which examines government’s progress on promises made relating to its levelling up agenda and finds that many have been broken, scaled back or represent a reduction to other pots of funding they replace. This, says the report, has had consequences for vital areas including jobs, net zero and education and skills, and could undermine political trust and participation. 

But despite this, claims the report, the north is demonstrating its potential with local people, communities and leaders doing what is needed to level up. For example, researchers found that the north generates 51% of England’s renewable energy demonstrating an example of ‘northern excellence’. However, they say that the region’s full potential can only be realised when central government is willing to devolve power to, and collaborate with, empowered regional and local government, and communities.

Arianna Giovannini, interim director of IPPR North, said: “Two years on from the promise to level up the country, government's rhetoric has reached fever pitch, but in reality they have once again over-promised and under-delivered on rebalancing our economy. To succeed in levelling up, enabling people everywhere to live a good life it will be necessary to build an economy hardwired for widespread prosperity, that powers the net zero transition, and provides everyone with access to high quality lifelong education.

“Broadening and deepening devolution, and building collaborative relationships between and across all levels of government are essential components of the levelling up jigsaw. But reorganising local government by the back door, false dawns, and further centralising power and funding would be a huge mistake and level down the country”.

Click here to download the IPPR 2021-22 State of the North report.